Records indicate Mitcham played its first organised match on 11 May 1907 against Payneham, losing 9.12.66 to 2.2.14. The first reference to the 'Mitcham Football Club' dates to 11 September 1907, where the Mitcham District Council approved the club's request to parade the streets on September 14. Mitcham began playing at the 'Long Paddocks' in Mitcham, before moving to Price Memorial Oval when it was opened in 1911, the ground to which we still call home. The club wore the double-blue colours of Sturt, a dark blue guernsey with light blue band around the middle.
Mitcham was an inaugural member of the Sturt Association in 1912, going undefeated to win its first premiership, then again in 1914, defeating Glenelg Imperial in the Grand Final.
In 1918, Mitcham competed in the Patriotic Association, a league formed during the First World War, competing against league clubs, including Sturt, Port Adelaide, West Adelaide, South Adelaide and West Torrens. Mitcham were required to change their colours to black with a green sash to avoid clashes with Sturt.
In 1919, the club reverted to its double-blue colours, this time in alternating vertical stripes, and played across two leagues - the SA Football Association and the Adelaide Imperial Association - before joining the United Suburban Football Association in 1920, winning the Grand Final but losing the premiership challenges match against Albert Park (as was permitted at the time).
In 1921, the club moved to the North Adelaide District Football League, winning its third premiership, before moving to the Mid-Southern Association in 1922, winning another premiership, defeating Brighton by 55 points.
In 1922, Mitcham played in an historic trial game against Sturt at Unley Oval, whereby Sturt threatened to strike due to former Sturt players being invited to play for Mitcham, resulting in police being called to reduce spectator angst. This match is widely documented.
The Mitcham Football Club's senior history is obscure from 1925 onwards, although Mitcham had a junior side in the South Suburban Colts Association based at Barren Reserve, believed to play against Church teams until the start of the Great Depression, in the late 1920s. From this point, there is no documented history available, indicating the club had gone into recess.
At the conclusion of the Second World War in 1945, the Mitcham Football Club was reformed by the boys and men at Mitcham Gymnasium, some of which had previously been involved with the club before the War. With the assistance of the Sturt Football Association and the Mitcham Council, the club was able to return to competition in 1946 as 'Mitcham Youth', competing in the Sturt District Football League (SDFL). For the first time, the club wore the royal blue and gold colours (blue jumper with gold V), when the Myer Emporium had for sale a cheap set of generic guernseys - our iconic colours we continue to wear to this day.
In 1947, the club reincorporated as the Mitcham District Football Club, competing the SDFL until 1962, which then became the Adelaide Metropolican Football League until its dissolution at the end of the 1967 season. Mitcham won four A Grade premierships in 1954, 1956, 1959 and 1960 while competing in the SDFL, along with a B Grade premiership in 1948.
In 1968, Mitcham joined the South Australian Amateur Football League (SAAFL), tasting immediate success in winning the A4 and A4R premiership (both undefeated), progressing into A3 in 1969 and then A2 in 1970. The club would also win it's first C Grade premiership in 1975 in the A8 division.
At the end of the 1975 season, Mitcham was asked to leave the SAAFL over a dispute relating to gate-takings, subsequently joined the Glenelg South Adelaide District Football Association from 1976-1984, winning two A Grade Premierships (1977 & 1984), one B Grade premiership (1976) and one C Grade premiership (1979).
In 1985, Mitcham rejoined the SAAFL in A6, narrowly losing the 1985 Grand Final. In 1987, the A Grade would win the A5 premiership in another undefeated season. The B Grade would win two premierships in 1993 and 1995 before the A Grade again tasted success, winning the 1996 A3 premiership, defeating St. Pauls.
Between 2005-2008, the club would enjoy a significant period of success, winning three B Grade premierships (2005, 2006, 2007) and one C Grade premiership (2007 - undefeated), while also unfortunately losing two A Grade Grand Finals (2006 & 2008), advancing the club to Division 3 of the SAAFL.
In 2018 and 2019, the B Grade would again win back-to-back premierships in incredible underdog circumstances.
In 2024, following a 28-year drought, the A Grade would finally win another premiership, defeating local-rival, Colonel Light Gardens by 65 points, marking the 14th A Grade premiership in our club's history
In 2018, the club would field its first Senior Women's side, culminating in a maiden premiership in 2020. The Senior Women have gone on to win two more premierships in W4 (2024) and W3 (2026).
Since 1998, Mitcham has run a successful Junior Football Program which currently competes in the SANFL Juniors competition. The club currently fields 16 junior sides from Under 7 to Under 18s in both the Boys and Girls competitions.